Decree 36 in Italian Parliament

Decree 36 & Law 74/2025: Understanding Italy’s Jure Sanguinis Overhaul in 2026

Executive Summary: Decree-Law No. 36 of March 28, 2025 (widely known as “Decree 36” or the “Tajani Decree”) was permanently converted into statute by the Italian Parliament through Law No. 74 of May 23, 2025 (implemented via Ministry of the Interior DAIT Circular No. 26185/2025). The reform introduced Article 3-bis into Law No. 91/1992, establishing a two-generation limit for dual nationals born abroad while safeguarding all administrative applications and judicial petitions filed on or before March 27, 2025 (23:59 CET). In 2026, Italy’s highest courts reshaped the post-Decree 36 landscape: the Supreme Court of Cassation’s United Sections (Rulings No. 24045/2026 and No. 24184/2026, followed by Circular No. 65050/2026) confirmed the strict non-retroactivity of Law No. 74/2025 and resolved the minor issue in favor of children born in jus soli countries under Article 7 of Law No. 555/1912, while the Constitutional Court (after Ruling No. 142/2025 and Ruling No. 63/2026) issued Order No. 147/2026 referring the generational cutoff to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) under Article 20 TFEU.

From Emergency Decree 36/2025 to Permanent Law No. 74/2025

When the Council of Ministers enacted Decree-Law No. 36 on March 28, 2025, it altered over a century of unrestricted jure sanguinis transmission under the 1865 Civil Code, Law No. 555/1912, and Law No. 91/1992. Under Article 77 of the Italian Constitution, Parliament had 60 days to amend and convert the emergency decree into permanent legislation.

On May 23, 2025, Parliament enacted Law No. 74/2025, followed on May 28, 2025 by Ministry of the Interior Circular No. 26185/2025. Rather than abolishing citizenship by descent, the converted statute inserted Article 3-bis into Law No. 91/1992, shifting Italian nationality law from an open multigenerational model to a filtered framework based on generational proximity, exclusive grandparent citizenship, or prior parental residence in Italy.

Core Provisions of Article 3-bis (Law No. 91/1992 as Amended by Law No. 74/2025)

In my practice, when I audit an applicant’s family tree against the converted provisions of Decree 36 / Law No. 74/2025, I verify five statutory benchmarks set forth in Article 3-bis:

Article 3-bis ProvisionLegal Requirement2026 Practical & Judicial Impact
Letters a) & a-bis) — March 27, 2025 SafeguardAdministrative application submitted (or appointment communicated) or judicial petition filed by March 27, 2025 (23:59 Rome time)Full Pre-Reform Protection: Confirmed as strictly non-retroactive by Cass. SSUU Rulings No. 24045/2026 and No. 24184/2026.
Letter b) — Pre-Cutoff Judicial Petitions (March 27, 2025 Safeguard)A parent or adoptive parent who is an Italian citizen was born in ItalyUnrestricted Recognition: Direct administrative or judicial recognition remains fully open.
Letter c) — 1st or 2nd-Degree Ascendant with Exclusively Italian Citizenship (Virgin Constitutional Question under Order 147/2026 §9.2)A citizen parent resided continuously in Italy for at least 2 years after acquiring citizenship and before the child’s birthGenuine Link Exemption: Bypasses generational limits regardless of how distant the original ancestor is.
Letter d) — Two-Year Parental Residence in Italy After Acquiring Citizenship & Before Child’s BirthAn Italian first-degree ascendant of the parent (grandparent) held exclusively Italian citizenship at the applicant’s birth or at deathTwo-Generation Cap: Requires documentary proof of non-naturalization / absence of dual nationality for the grandparent.
3rd Generation+ (Great-Grandparents & Beyond)Lineage exceeding the 2nd degree without pre-cutoff filing or 2-year parental residenceSubject to 2026 Strategic Litigation: Challenged via CJEU Referral Order No. 147/2026, Prenot@mi impedimento incolpevole, or 1948 maternal double-discrimination claims.

How the 2026 High Court Rulings Reshaped Decree 36 and Law No. 74/2025

Understanding Decree 36 today requires analyzing the landmark decisions issued by the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of Cassation in 2025 and 2026:

1. Supreme Court United Sections Rulings No. 24045/2026 & No. 24184/2026 (and Circular No. 65050/2026)

In United Sections Ruling No. 24045/2026 (and Ruling No. 24184/2026), the Supreme Court of Cassation delivered two major victories for Italian descendants. First, it rejected the government’s attempt to apply Law No. 74/2025 retroactively to pre-March 27, 2025 cases. Second, it resolved the minor issue by ruling that Article 7 of Law No. 555/1912 acts as a special safeguard for children born in jus soli countries, preventing the loss of Italian citizenship under Article 12 when a parent naturalized abroad during the child’s minority. Following this ruling, the Ministry of the Interior issued Circular No. 65050/2026, formally revoking the restrictive 2024 directive (Circular No. 43347/2024).

2. Constitutional Court Rulings No. 142/2025, No. 63/2026, and CJEU Referral Order No. 147/2026

After addressing initial pre-reform challenges in Ruling No. 142/2025, the Constitutional Court examined the domestic constitutionality of Article 3-bis in Ruling No. 63/2026. Crucially, however, the Constitutional Court subsequently issued Order No. 147/2026, referring Law No. 74/2025 to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in Luxembourg. Because stripping or denying Member State nationality simultaneously extinguishes European Union citizenship under Article 20 TFEU, the CJEU will rule on whether an automatic generational cutoff without an individualized proportionality assessment violates EU law (under the Rottmann and Tjebbes doctrines).

Strategic Legal Pathways If You Are Affected by Decree 36 / Law No. 74/2025

  • 1948 Maternal Line Petitions (Double Discrimination Defense): Descendants claiming through a female ancestor who gave birth prior to January 1, 1948 were legally barred from applying at a consulate before March 27, 2025. In my judicial petitions before the competent District Courts, I argue that applying Article 3-bis to 1948 maternal cases inflicts unconstitutional double discrimination under Articles 3 and 24 of the Constitution.
  • Inculpable Impediment (Prenot@mi Blockage) & CJEU Suspension Motions: For applicants who documented concrete attempts to book a consular appointment before March 27, 2025, I build evidentiary dossiers invoking impedimento incolpevole alongside motions to stay proceedings pending the CJEU’s judgment under Order No. 147/2026.
  • Article 10-bis Administrative Rebuttals: If a consulate or municipality issues a pre-rejection notice citing Law No. 74/2025 or historical naturalization issues, I file a targeted Article 10-bis legal response within the 10-day window.

Legislative History & Complementary Bill DDL 1450 (MAECI Reform, 48-Month Cap & 25-Year Rule)

The landscape of Italian citizenship ius sanguinis (by right of blood) has been thrown into unprecedented turmoil. In late March 2025, the Italian government enacted emergency measures drastically altering the rules, including the impactful Decree 36 , followed swiftly by parliamentary proposals suggesting even further…

This post aims to unravel the complexity, clarify the current legal situation regarding Decree 36 and related bills, outline the proposed changes, and explore the potential scenarios unfolding in the Italian Parliament over the crucial coming weeks. You can follow related developments on our news page .

Untangling the Legislative Web: Decree 36, DDL 1432, and DDL 1450

Understanding the current situation requires differentiating between three key pieces of legislation:

  • Decree-Law No. 36 of March 28, 2025 (“Decreto Tajani”) (DL 36/2025): This is the immediately effective emergency decree, commonly known as Decree 36, that triggered the current crisis. Published and enacted rapidly, it introduced severe restrictions on ius sanguinis citizenship , particularly for those born abroad. Its…
  • Bill No. 1432 (DDL 1432): This is the conversion bill for Decree 36 (DL 36/2025), currently under examination in the Italian Senate (specifically, the 1st Commission – Constitutional Affairs). Parliament must debate, potentially amend, and vote on converting DL 36/2025 into permanent law (or let it expire) by May 27, 2…
  • Bill No. 1450 (DDL 1450): This is a separate, complementary bill introduced in the Senate shortly after Decree 36. It proposes additional, distinct modifications to the primary Citizenship Law (Law 91/1992). It is not yet law and follows a standard parliamentary path, distinct from the urgent conversion of DL 36. The i…

Deconstructing Decree 36 and Related Proposals: Content and Status

  • Core Change: Introduces a new Article 3-bis into Law 91/1992. It establishes that individuals born abroad with another citizenship are “considered never to have acquired” Italian citizenship unless specific conditions are met. This phrasing controversially frames the issue as non-acquisition ab origine, rather than a l…
  • Retroactive Cut-Off: The restrictions apply retroactively to anyone born abroad before March 28, 2025, unless they had formally submitted a complete administrative application or filed a court case by 11:59 PM (Rome time) on March 27, 2025.
  • New Conditions (Exceptions to Exclusion): To be considered Italian despite being born abroad with dual nationality and missing the deadline, an applicant must meet at least one of these conditions (Art. 3-bis, letters c, d, e): An Italian parent (or adoptive parent) was born in Italy. An Italian parent (or adoptive par…
  • An Italian parent (or adoptive parent) was resident in Italy for at least two consecutive years immediately prior to the applicant’s birth/adoption.
  • An Italian grandparent (parent of the Italian parent/adopter) was born in Italy.
  • Constitutional Concerns: Legal experts (as cited in the provided article and hearing summaries, like this one: Senate Hearing Summary PDF ) have fiercely criticized Decree 36 for: Violating Legal Certainty and Acquired Rights: Applying new, restrictive conditions retroactively to rights potentially acquired at birth un…
  • Violating Legal Certainty and Acquired Rights: Applying new, restrictive conditions retroactively to rights potentially acquired at birth under previous laws.
  • Potential Violation of Equality (Art. 3 Const.): Discriminating based on place of birth (Italy vs. abroad) and application timing.
  • Circumventing Art. 22 Const.: Which prohibits deprivation of citizenship for political reasons; critics argue Decree 36 achieves a similar result through legislative fiat.
  • Improper Use of Emergency Decree (Art. 77 Const.): Using urgent measures for a fundamental, non-sudden issue, bypassing proper parliamentary deliberation. The government cited the need to prevent a flood of applications as justification.
  • Lack of Proportionality and Procedural Safeguards: Especially concerning potential impacts on EU citizenship rights , as highlighted by Professor Grosso citing CJEU jurisprudence. Issues regarding potential challenges before the Italian Constitutional Court are significant.

B. Bill for Conversion (DDL 1432) – Currently Under Senate Review

  • Process: Currently undergoing review in the Senate’s 1st Commission. Hearings with experts (De Nardi, Laganà, Calvano, Grosso, etc.) have taken place, revealing deep divisions and strong critiques. Numerous amendments (see list: List of Amendments DDL 1432 – Senate ) have been proposed by MPs and have now been official…
  • Removing retroactivity (e.g., making it apply only after enactment – Amendments 1.9, 1.10, 1.11, 1.12, 1.13).
  • Modifying or broadening the exception conditions (e.g., referring to Italian citizenship of parent/grandparent instead of birth in Italy – Amendments 1.29, 1.30, 1.40; extending to second/third generation – Amendments 1.37, 1.41, 1.47, 1.50; adding language/cultural ties – Amendments 1.50, 1.51; considering siblings al…
  • Reopening terms for reclaiming citizenship lost under previous laws (Amendments 1.77, 1.78, 1.79, 1.86, 1.87, 1.88).
  • Status: The 1st Commission was expected to finalize amendment proposals by April 16th (though the provided summary is dated April 23rd, suggesting the process is ongoing/reporting delayed). The bill will then move to the full Senate floor.

C. Complementary Bill (DDL 1450) – Proposed, Not Yet Law

  • Purpose: To introduce further, separate amendments to Law 91/1992. It appears to be a broader reform effort, potentially incorporating elements deemed unsuitable for the emergency Decree 36.
  • Key Proposed Changes (based on OCR text): Residency Requirements for Parents: Modifying Art. 1 & 3 to potentially deny citizenship if citizen parents born abroad haven’t resided in Italy for 2 years before the child’s birth/adoption and their own parents (applicant’s grandparents) were also born abroad. Minor Children:…
  • Residency Requirements for Parents: Modifying Art. 1 & 3 to potentially deny citizenship if citizen parents born abroad haven’t resided in Italy for 2 years before the child’s birth/adoption and their own parents (applicant’s grandparents) were also born abroad.
  • Minor Children: Amending Art. 4 to allow minor children of citizens by birth to acquire citizenship if parents declare intent and the child subsequently resides legally in Italy for 2 years. This relates to complex minor issue cases .
  • Marriage: Removing the specific 3-year residency abroad period for citizenship by marriage (Art. 5).
  • Processing Times: Setting a 48-month deadline for processing ius sanguinis recognition applications (Art. 9-ter, new 1-bis). Setting a 12-month deadline for state civil registrars to execute court judgments (Art. 9-ter, new 1-ter). This is relevant for those facing consulate appointment delays .
  • Maintaining Ties (“25-Year Rule”): Introducing Art. 11-bis, stating citizens born abroad and non-resident lose citizenship if they hold another nationality and don’t maintain “effective ties” with Italy for 25 years after the law’s entry into force. Failure to register birth within 25 years creates a presumption of los…
  • Renunciation Presumption: Amending Art. 13 to presume renunciation if residency in Italy (required for certain citizenship recovery paths) is less than 2 years.
  • Children of Re-acquirers: Clarifying Art. 14 that children acquire citizenship when a parent re-acquires it only if the child is legally resident in Italy at that time (or from birth if under 2).
  • Retroactivity Clause: Amending Art. 20 to explicitly subordinate its non-retroactivity principle to the new Art. 3-bis (introduced by Decree 36).
  • Proof Limitations: Adding Art. 23-bis to disallow oaths and witness testimony in citizenship matters (reinforcing Dr. Laganà’s concern, relevant for document inconsistencies ).
  • 1948 Cases : Adding an interpretative clause confirming that children of Italian mothers born before Jan 1, 1948, are considered citizens if they were under 21 on that date.
  • Consular Fees: Increasing the fee from €600 to €700 (Art. 7-bis of consular fee table) and adjusting budget law references.
  • Status: This bill is separate from the Decree 36 conversion. Its path through Parliament will be longer and subject to the standard legislative process. It reflects a broader governmental vision for tightening citizenship rules, potentially influenced by political considerations discussed here .

Potential Scenarios for Decree 36 Conversion (DDL 1432) and Legal Implications

The next few weeks are critical as the Senate processes DDL 1432 (the conversion of Decree 36). Based on parliamentary procedure and the political context (as outlined in the user’s provided analysis):

  • Scenario 1: Amendments Accepted Freely: The government allows the Senate to amend the bill significantly, potentially softening or removing the harshest aspects (like retroactivity). Likelihood: Low, unless amendments align with the coalition’s goals.
  • Scenario 2: Confidence Vote on Original Decree 36: The government forces a vote on the decree exactly as written, nuking all amendments. Likelihood: Possible but perhaps politically costly. If declared a confidence matter, it would likely pass, as defeat means government resignation.
  • Scenario 3: Confidence Vote on a “Maxi-Amendment”: The government negotiates a compromise amendment package behind closed doors with coalition partners and forces a confidence vote on that version, nuking all other amendments. Likelihood: High. This is a common tactic for decree conversions. The nature of this compromi…
  • Scenario 4: Decree Expires: The government fails to secure conversion by May 27, and Decree 36 (DL 36) lapses ex tunc (as if it never existed). Likelihood: Considered Unlikely by many observers, given the government’s strong push.
  • Those who met the March 27 deadline: Are safe under Decree 36, evaluated under the old rules.
  • Those who missed the deadline: Currently face the restrictive conditions of Decree 36. Their hope lies in the conversion process (Scenarios 1, 3 with favorable amendments, or 4) or a future successful constitutional challenge.
  • Future Applicants: Will be subject to whatever final version of the law emerges from the conversion process and potentially the separate changes proposed in DDL 1450 if it passes later.
  • Recognized Citizens Born Abroad (passing to children): Decree 36 currently imposes the 2-year residency requirement on the parent before the child’s birth. DDL 1450 proposes an alternative: the child can acquire citizenship by living in Italy for 2 years after birth. The final law remains uncertain. Consulates appear t…
  • Constitutional Challenge: Regardless of the conversion outcome (unless Decree 36 lapses or is drastically amended), a challenge before the Italian Constitutional Court seems highly probable given the profound legal critiques. Such cases could suspend application processing until a ruling is issued.

Decree 36: A Troubling Approach to Fundamental Rights

The manner in which these changes, particularly through Decree 36, have been introduced raises profound concerns. As highlighted by the commentary article (“La Grande Perdita”) and numerous legal experts during Senate hearings (Calvano, Grosso, Laganà):

  • Superficiality vs. Delicacy: Fundamental rights related to citizenship, status, and family unity are being altered with alarming speed and apparent disregard for established legal principles. The use of an emergency decree circumvents the thoughtful deliberation typically required for such sensitive matters under Itali…
  • Retroactivity’s Harsh Impact: The attempt to retroactively strip individuals of a status potentially held since birth, based on criteria they could not have foreseen, fundamentally undermines legal certainty and fairness (“scam of labels” – Grosso; “legislative axe” – Calvano).
  • Erosion of Rights: The measures represent a significant departure from Italy’s traditionally inclusive ius sanguinis principle , potentially severing ties with large diaspora communities whose emigration was once encouraged and whose connection Italy has historically sought to maintain.

Conclusion: Uncertainty Reigns, Vigilance Required for Decree 36

The Italian government has initiated a radical and controversial overhaul of citizenship ius sanguinis, spearheaded by Decree 36. The situation is highly fluid, with the immediate focus on the Senate’s handling of DDL 1432 to convert the emergency decree DL 36/2025. The separate proposals in DDL 1450 add another layer …

The clash between the state’s asserted need for control and the fundamental rights and legitimate expectations of its diaspora is stark. The introduction of retroactive measures via Decree 36 represents a concerning approach to constitutional principles.

Individuals affected by these changes must stay informed as the parliamentary process unfolds in the coming weeks and consult closely with qualified legal counsel (consider reviewing our past posts for background) to understand the implications for their specific situation and navigate the potential legal challenges ah…

A: Decree 36 is an emergency decree-law enacted by the Italian government on March 28, 2025. It significantly restricts the rules for recognizing Italian citizenship by descent (ius sanguinis) , particularly for individuals born abroad, and controversially applies these restrictions retroactively. You can read more abo…

A: Decree 36 states that individuals born abroad with another citizenship are considered never Italian unless they met a deadline (March 27, 2025, for applications/court cases) OR have an Italian parent/grandparent born in Italy, OR an Italian parent resident in Italy for two years before their birth.

A: Yes, the most controversial aspect of Decree 36 is its retroactive application. It applies the new restrictive conditions even to those born before the decree’s enactment date, unless they met the specified deadline.

A: Individuals of Italian descent born outside Italy, who hold another citizenship, and who had not formally applied for citizenship recognition or filed a court case by March 27, 2025, are most affected. Their eligibility now depends on meeting the new, stricter conditions related to their parents’ or grandparents’ bi…

A: Currently, Decree 36 is temporary emergency legislation. The Italian Parliament (Senate, then Chamber of Deputies) must vote to convert it into permanent law (potentially with amendments via bill DDL 1432, trackable here ) by May 27, 2025. If not converted, it will expire.

The emergency decree has now been officially converted into law. Full details on the final version are in my analysis of Italy citizenship law change 2025 .

For cases impacted by strict judicial readings of the 2025 decrees, explore how to obtain a Corte d’Appello review for citizenship rejections before a three-judge panel.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Did Decree 36 become permanent law in Italy?

Yes. Decree-Law No. 36/2025 was converted with amendments into Law No. 74 of May 23, 2025, which inserted Article 3-bis into Law No. 91/1992. Its generational restrictions are currently under preliminary review before the Court of Justice of the European Union pursuant to Constitutional Court Order No. 147/2026.

Does Decree 36 / Law No. 74/2025 affect applications filed before March 27, 2025?

No. Both the statutory safeguard clause in Article 3-bis and Supreme Court United Sections Rulings No. 24045/2026 and No. 24184/2026 establish that all administrative applications and judicial petitions filed on or before March 27, 2025 (23:59 CET) are governed by pre-reform law.

What happened to the minor issue after Law No. 74/2025?

The Supreme Court’s United Sections (Rulings No. 24045/2026 and No. 24184/2026) and Ministry Circular No. 65050/2026 resolved the minor issue in favor of descendants born in jus soli countries, confirming that Article 7 of Law No. 555/1912 preserved the child’s Italian citizenship despite a parent’s foreign naturalization.

Evaluate Your Citizenship Eligibility Under Law No. 74/2025 and the 2026 Rulings

Whether your lineage is affected by the generational limits of Decree 36 / Law No. 74/2025, a 1948 maternal line, or consular booking barriers, I personally review your genealogical documents in my practice to determine your strongest legal pathway under Supreme Court Rulings No. 24045/2026 and No. 24184/2026, Circular No. 65050/2026, and CJEU Referral Order No. 147/2026.

The fee for a strategic video consultation and preliminary case assessment is €250 all-in total (taxes included). The consultation fee (€250) is 100% credited toward the legal fees of your subsequent judicial petition (pursuant to D.M. 55/2014).

Avv. Michele Vitale
Avv. Michele Vitale
Author & Legal Reviewer

Avv. Michele Vitale

Italian Citizenship Lawyer • Avvocato iscritto all'Albo degli Avvocati presso il Foro di Larino

Avvocato iscritto all'Albo degli Avvocati presso il Foro di Larino. Studio Legale: Via Ruffini 29/A, 86039 Termoli (CB), Italy — P.IVA 01876430701. Specializzato nel contenzioso giudiziale per il riconoscimento della cittadinanza italiana iure sanguinis (linea materna 1948, ritardi consolari ex L. 241/90, difese avverso preavvisi di rigetto art. 10-bis e rimessioni nomofilattiche post-Cassazione SSUU 24045/2026 e L. 74/2025). Iscrizione verificabile pubblicamente sul registro ufficiale del Consiglio Nazionale Forense (CNF).

Need direct legal assistance on your Italian citizenship case?
Schedule a comprehensive 1-on-1 strategy consultation directly with Avv. Michele Vitale.
Book Legal Consultation — €250 all-in total (taxes included) →

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *